Jonathan has helped optimize...

« Busy Being Born: Creative Technology & Analytics | Main | Transcendence: The Power of Publishing is Marketing »

Google Stripping Referring URL Parameters Will Leave Many Naked

Hash

Back in early February Google did a little test. It decided to test an AJAX SERP. This meant Google sent natural search result traffic to sites without any passing identifying parameters except the top-level domain google.com. Message Boards and Blogs lit up immediately. They stopped the test (to 10% of traffic) quickly but in March seemed to try it again. Two weeks ago, Google followed-up with announced change of URL parameters. Some good and some bad. This week Google again seems to be rolling out AJAX SERPs this time more extensively for Firefox users. Something is happening here.

It has become clear that we are all Google’s Mr. Jones. The Google Mothership seems to be leaving and we can choose to get onboard for the data ride (Google Analytics would likely still be able to capture queries and the like) or we can live in a netherworld of insufficient data. With some sites getting 50% or more of their traffic from Google natural search not using GA in this scenario relegates them to a sort of third world of data and renders their subscription-based analytics platforms limp.

There is no question in my mind that Google owns this referrer data though I have heard it argued otherwise from the analytics vendors. The click action takes place in the Google domain and though the link data is generated from publisher content, publishers are under no obligation to have their sites indexed. There is also no question to its value. Huge. It is worth mentioning that much of the URL shorteners now driving an ever growing amount of web traffic pass even less useful referrer parameters to the linked sites.

This is Google's nuclear option to the world of web data. The fallout will be an analytic winter for many. The face of the analytics, SEO, online publishing, testing, targeting and even the public markets will all change. Does the very fact that Google has so much data leverage mean they are likely to use it to their advantage at some point? Would it be so bad to live in a world of (free) GA? They have made great strides with segmentation and continue to add data visualization. Of course there are plenty of reasons ethical, historical and rational that Google must leave their URL passable and parseable. It appears now less likely than ever to happen.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341ccaa353ef01156f65f7c0970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Google Stripping Referring URL Parameters Will Leave Many Naked:

Comments

Hi Jonathan,

this is going to be big isn't it?

GA aggregates data - I don't think we can drill down to individual clickstreams. And we certainly can't see/ analyse/ react to it in real time.

And what is this going to do to mashups ads? That music store ad, the expedia hotels, the dockers pants - all of these are going to be revalued aren't they?

I guess I have never really pondered who owns the click - I guess you are correct. It is Google's.

Bummer.

Maybe they'll release a paid real-time referrer feed?

Cheers

I would have imagined you were above hearsay and conspiracy Mr. Mendez!

Google, like Microsoft and Yahoo! and Ask and others, realizes that the best customer is a data driven customer. It would be imprudent to do anything that would stand in the way.

I'll leave the ownership issues to Pundits (and Bloggers : )), but the Search team at Google announced the change well in advance To Ensure that all vendors (Google Analytics included) have time to make relevant changes to the data processing if required.

WebTrends, Omniture and other vendors have posted on their blogs that their Analytics solutions will be fine with this change.

In fact they have said that they are making minor changes to incorporate *additional* data / goodies that may or may not be in the new referrer string. : )

Thanks Jonathan.

Avinash.

Derek- I think this amplifies the use/need of semantic and contextual rules on the publisher side. Lots of targeting can still be done but it is up to pubs to figure out how. We've got a ways to go there but the tools are getting better.

Avinash- Thanks for stopping by. Far from being heresy and conspiracy the AJAX SERP has been stripping URL parameters on and off for three months now to certain percentages of traffic. I've been following this for the past couple of months and it was seeing that once again this "testing" is going on on Google own support forum.

To date we've only heard Matt's PR like statements and Brett's comment that he was "seeking clarification from the search team." So quite a bit of data has already been lost for people. If you know of anyone that has been able to capture parameter data stripped from the URLs due to AJAX please let me know. I've been following this closely and have not heard of that.

I'm sure the vendors will make statement that things will be fine. I'm not as confident, but still hopeful.

Cheers,

Jonathan


This is really interesting, I've often wondered how people track changes in Googles "tracking system" - and thats when i realised... if you dont use Analytics, and use a third party stats package it becomes much more transparent when changes occur...

As an after thought, i'm now going to install two tracking packages on every website so I can compare data.

yea,welcome to site www.wellbiznet.com to have a look.

Gifts to Sri Lanka, Flowers to Sri Lanka, Cakes to Sri Lanka,Same Day delivery all over Sri Lanka and colombo
http://www.lankaflorist.com

The comments to this entry are closed.